I have my front page set to a static page and a different page set up for the Blog Post Index page. All works fine except when I try to protect the Blog Post Index page with membership plugins. The Blog Post Index page never gets protected and all who enter the site can view it whether or not they are signed in.
All other pages are being protected properly.
I am currently using s2members, but have tried other membership plugins with the same results.
What is the trick to make sure the Blog Post Index page can be protected?