This is a limitation in the Infinite Scroll script that we’re using, in that in can only fetch the “next” page, and not “previous” page, which technically is how WordPress linked to the older comments when you have the comments displayed in reverse chronological order.
I’ve dug deeper into the code and modified it to include that use case. It will be working in the next update.
This free Support Forum relies on contributions from our support staffs and fellow Graphene themes users. While we endeavour to provide adequate and timely support, due to its voluntary nature responses are not guaranteed and may be delayed.
If you require urgent assistance, you may like to consider our Priority Support option.